Learn about global crypto tax frameworks, tax implications for NFTs, strategies for tax-loss harvesting, and best practices for staying compliant in the cryptocurrency landscape.
Sep 11 2024 | ArticleFrom a fringe curiosity, cryptocurrencies have advanced into a global financial force. And with growth came the watchful regulatory eye. For many early adopters, the arrival of crypto felt like liberation, a way out from the traditional financial systems. However, as it became clear to the governments of the world that blockchain and digital assets represented a tremendous future potential, they quickly moved to regulate. A field that evolved at a very rapid pace is crypto taxation, and being able to understand how to tread in this space of crypto taxes is paramount for any investor or trader within the said space.
Due to the decentralized nature of blockchain technology, the taxation of cryptocurrencies would differ greatly from traditional asset taxes.
Whether you're a casual user of Web3, an active day trader, or you actually earn your living in cryptocurrency, tax liabilities can vary widely from one geographical location and type of activity to the next. The purchase and selling of coins, staking, mining, or being paid in cryptocurrencies—these are just a few among the wide variety of transactions that can be made. For many, this is where the confusion begins.
Imagine that you're playing a game, and every time it changes, you make a move while new rules are being thrown at you, often kind of fuzzy. This is the state of crypto taxation today: ever-evolving, often unclear, and highly dependent on jurisdiction. In this guide, we break down the complexity of cryptocurrencies in tax, making it more comprehensible for you to remain compliant while building your financial strategy.
One of the reasons why cryptocurrency taxation is so complex: many crypto assets do not fit neatly into existing tax frameworks. Cryptos, unlike traditional stocks or real estate, serve a variety of purposes: they can be traded, staked, mined, even used as a form of payment. Each one of those actions triggers different tax implications, and often the challenge lies in determining when a taxable event has occurred.
For instance, one could purchase some Bitcoin, afterward change it to Ethereum, and in the end even stake Ethereum in a DeFi platform to realize rewards. At any of those points, it's potentially a tax event. Buying and selling Bitcoin and Ethereum are usually treated like selling property and taxed on the gains. However, the user staking his/her Ethereum might consider those earnings from staking. This matters because taxes of different sorts will apply and one easily falls into a muddle if everything is not carefully tracked.
In most jurisdictions, a cryptocurrency is classified not as a currency but rather as property. At first glance, this seems confusing, especially as people use cryptocurrencies to make payments for things.
But treating crypto like property means that every time you sell, trade, or even spend it, you have to pay capital gains tax.Your gain or loss is the difference between what you paid for the cryptocurrency (its cost basis) and what you sold or traded it for (its fair market value at the time of the transaction).
For example, you bought 1 Bitcoin at $10,000. A year later, you take this Bitcoin to buy another new car, the same $40,000. For tax purposes, you have now effectively sold the Bitcoin for $40,000, so you will owe capital gains tax on the $30,000 profit, even though you got no cash, but bought something using the crypto. That differentiation caught most first-time cryptocurrency users by surprise, especially since every transaction, even using cryptocurrency to buy coffee, could trigger a taxable event.
It is very crucial to understand what constitutes a taxable event so that you can manage your crypto taxes. A taxable event happens whenever an exchange occurs that potentially results in a realized gain or loss. Here are some of the most common examples of taxable events:
Take, for example, a day trader who is actively trading several cryptocurrencies. If they trade from Bitcoin to Ethereumon Monday and then from Ethereum to Cardano on Tuesday, they've incurred two taxable events. That means each transaction must be considered separately, with taxes being owed based on the gains or losses stemming from each transaction.
Keeping a log for all these events, as you'll need to report the fair market value of the cryptocurrency at the time of each transaction, is the most cumbersome aspect of maintaining crypto taxes; it becomes even trickier if you have multiple wallets, exchanges, and DeFi platforms in play.
When it comes to buying and selling cryptocurrency, knowing the tax implications can save you from unforeseen liabilities. In most countries, exchanging cryptocurrency for fiat money such as USD or EUR does not cause any kind oftaxable event. However, when you sell that cryptocurrency, you realize a capital gains tax liability on any appreciation from the time that you bought it until you sold it.
For example, if you bought 1 Ethereum at $2,000 and later sold it for $4,000, the $2,000 profit would be considered capital gain, which you would be obliged to pay taxes on. The duration of your possession of Ethereum will determine whether you will pay short-term or long-term capital gains tax rates.
Crypto-to-crypto trades, such as exchanging Bitcoin for Ethereum, are taxable events. For instance, buying 0.5 Bitcoin at $15,000 and later on, when the cost of one Bitcoin was already $20,000, you exchanged it for 5 Ethereum; you would have made a $5,000 gain in your taxes, though you did not convert it into fiat currency.
Mining and staking rewards are taken to be ordinary income. For example, if you mine 0.1 BTC, which is valued at $6,000 when the coin is received, you will be required to report that as a taxable income of $6,000. Staking rewards work in exactly the same way. If you earn 0.2 ETH from staking, which is worth $500 when you receive it, then that will have to be the amount you consider taxably received.
If you receive payment for goods or services in any cryptocurrency, this counts as taxable income. For example, if you were paid 1 Bitcoin worth $30,000, then that amount of money will be reported as your income just as if you were paid in fiat.
Giving and receiving of cryptocurrency as a gift, donation, or inheritance can be taxed based on local legislation. In most countries, however, when crypto is given as a gift, the gift itself is not taxed, with the receiver being liable for the giver's original cost basis. Donations to qualified charities may be tax deductible based on the fair market value of the cryptocurrency at the time of donation.
The IRS views cryptocurrency as property. Taxable events are the sale, trade, or use of crypto to make purchases, which will trigger capital gains. Earning crypto through mining or staking is taxed as ordinary income. With this, the IRS has upped its game to ensure that transactions by crypto users are reported.
In the United Kingdom, HMRC classifies cryptocurrencies as property. This means capital gains tax applies to gains above the annual tax-free allowance. However, in the UK, crypto-to-crypto trades are not taxed, thus making it more preferable for active traders as compared to the US.
Tax rules are very different in the European Union: in terms of capital gains taxation, there is on an exempt ofcryptocurrencies held for more than a year, while Germany and France impose a flat 30% gain. Meanwhile, Portugal doesn't tax personal cryptocurrency gains, making its regime one of the best.
Singapore imposes no capital gains tax on crypto, while for Japan, taxes on crypto as miscellaneous income run up to 55%. India recently announced a 30% crypto income tax—a pretty harsh regime.
One of the biggest challenges when it comes to calculating crypto taxes is tracking multiple wallets and exchanges. Such transactions of buying, selling, trading, or transferring cryptocurrencies could all be probable taxable events, hencetracking needs to be precise. Lacking proper tracking makes the determination of gains or losses practically impossible.
The ability to determine the cost basis—of an original value of your crypto at acquisition—could be problematic because the price of cryptos moves very fast, and for a trader dealing with different cryptocurrencies, it is a more complex affair.
Most users resort to crypto tax software to simplify this process. Tools such as Koinly, TokenTax, and CoinTrackingcould integrate with exchanges and wallets to get the transactions and then calculate gains for tax reporting purposes.
Harvesting tax losses allows an investor to sell losing investments in order to offset gains and reduce their tax liabilities. This can be particularly useful in the volatile crypto market. For instance, if you have gains from selling Bitcoin but you actually have losses from selling Altcoin XYZ, you could sell your altcoins to help net against the taxes due on your Bitcoin gains.
Making losses can be a good thing when well-timed; prices for cryptocurrencies sometimes go up and down, therefore the sale must be done in such a manner that will coincide with this kind of tax-saving strategy.
NFTs are taxed similarly to cryptocurrencies. When NFTs are sold for a profit, that can be a taxable capital gain event, and you could have to pay ordinary income tax if you create and then sell NFTs. For example, if you purchased an NFT with 1 ETH ($2,000) and later sold it with 2 ETH ($6,000), you would pay taxes on $4,000 in profit.
Artists and NFT creators usually pay tax on the income generated from the initial sale. However, when a buyer resells the NFT, the profits which arise out of the sale of NFT are generally taxable under capital gain.
With authorities such as the IRS and HMRC taxing it, ensuring that you stay compliant is important. Failure to report crypto transactions correctly can translate into fines, penalties, or criminal charges.
Professionals can really help answer questions about the complexity of crypto taxes—for example, how to deal with relevant global tax laws and strategies for tax-loss harvesting or even local regulation compliance.
Proper record-keeping is key in this context. All transactions need to be tracked, with the date and amount in each case recorded at fair value at the time of the trade. This information needs to be properly reported. Crypto tax software could help in the whole process and smoothly connect to exchanges to generate detailed reports automatically.
Governments worldwide are coming together to develop standardized frameworks for taxing cryptocurrencies. In this regard, the OECD played an instrumental role in ensuring that tax loopholes are closed, most importantly for cross-border crypto transactions.
We could be right in assuming that new norms will one day regulate DeFi, NFTs, and staking, given the lack of clarity about those areas in many jurisdictions. Governments might also introduce new tax structures for unrealized gains or wealth taxes targeting digital assets.
Crypto tax is a space that can get complex, but with good education and organization, it can save you from makingexpensive mistakes. Know what constitutes a taxable event, apply strategies like tax-loss harvesting, and employ the right professionals and tools to secure compliance while striving for an optimal tax outcome. Therefore, getting ahead of the curve, in a rapidly growing crypto space, is quintessential for anyone to be in it.